MY LITTLE DILEMMA

For some reason, I keep finding myself in tough decisions. So why don't I ask my friends? Okay then.

SO, you may have remembered a little while back me ranting about this person who gets on my nerves. Basically, some of my friends are saying I should forgive him, so now I am wondering if I should. He's said some pretty hurtful things to me, but I've said a few bad things to him as well- but I'm still debating whether I should forgive him.

Reasons for:

-We see each other a fair amount and it will be less awkward.
-We've agreed on a few things and have had a couple of jokes.
-I have said and done a few things myself.
-Peace is better and it will help me be happier.
-If he says anything else mean to me he may be in trouble.

Against:

-He's called me (and some of my friends) bad things.
-He can be rude, arrogant and a pain.
-He generally annoys me.
-He generally isn't too nice.
-I just generally am annoyed when he is near.

So what do you think? I'm still pondering on whether I should forgive him or not. I'll see what happens tomorrow...